Previewing Intel's Threadripper 2 Killer??

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 27 сен 2018
  • Check out Videoblocks today at www.videoblocks.com/LinusTechTips
    Intel has shown off a 28 core monster running at 5GHz during Computex. We set out to emulate its performance in-house.
    Buy Xeon Platinum 8180 on Amazon: geni.us/htaq
    Buy AMD Threadripper 2990WX on Amazon: geni.us/PMaV
    Discuss on the forum: linustechtips.com/main/topic/976741-previewing-intels-threadripper-2-killer-intel-xeon-platinum-8180-vs-amd-threadripper-2990wx/
    Our Affiliates, Referral Programs, and Sponsors: linustechtips.com/main/topic/75969-linus-tech-tips-affiliates-referral-programs-and-sponsors
    Linus Tech Tips merchandise at www.designbyhumans.com/shop/LinusTechTips/
    Linus Tech Tips posters at crowdmade.com/linustechtips
    Our Test Benches on Amazon: www.amazon.com/shop/linustechtips
    Our production gear: geni.us/cvOS
    Twitter - twitter.com/linustech
    Facebook - facebook.com/LinusTech
    Instagram - instagram.com/linustech
    Twitch - www.twitch.tv/linustech
    Intro Screen Music Credit:
    Title: Laszlo - Supernova
    Video Link: ru-clip.com/video/PKfxmFU3lWY/видео.html
    iTunes Download Link: itunes.apple.com/us/album/supernova/id936805712
    Artist Link: soundcloud.com/laszlomusic
    Outro Screen Music Credit: Approaching Nirvana - Sugar High ru-clip.com/user/approachingnirvana
    Sound effects provided by www.freesfx.co.uk/sfx/
  • Наука и техникаНаука и техника

Комментарии • 3 454

  • Jason Terry
    Jason Terry 6 дней назад

    i'm pc robin hood. give me your cpu cores or else.

  • HeatedSnail
    HeatedSnail 13 дней назад

    You should have tried it with 4way sli for games because threadripper has 64 pcie lanes

  • Joseph Jennings
    Joseph Jennings 14 дней назад

    @Linus Have you considered redoing this video with undervolting the AMD ThreadRipper for the gaming performance comparison portion? There have been a significant number of videos that show that undervolting AMD CPUs ends up yielding higher results. I do not personally know this to be true and would trust if more if it came from you.

  • Sic Semper Evello Mortem Tyrannis
    Sic Semper Evello Mortem Tyrannis 29 дней назад

    I'm still running an i7 4960X, but i've always been an Intel guy, but now im definitely gonna go with a threadripper on my next rig, glad to see AMD is giving Intel a run for their money (and hopefully it makes Intel stop running for everyone else's money).

  • Stephen Davidson
    Stephen Davidson Месяц назад

    10k ? Holy shit intel

  • Nova Exclusives
    Nova Exclusives Месяц назад

    Please upvote for visibility:
    I currently own a 2990WX and at 3.4GHZ with all cores populated running a compression job through Bandizip, I'm seeing full core utilization AND this 3.55TB compression job which took over FOUR DAYS on my i7-5820k @ 4.2GHZ is now cut to about 12 hours, all for the SAME DAMN PRICE I SPENT ON THE INTEL BUILD. For those who want to call me a shill, please look up my name on IG (no space) and see that I am not invested in sponsors or computing, but I'm a 90's baby who grew up respecting how far these machines have come. I make upgrades with a very different philosophy than most, since it requires strength of will and dedication to know that settling is literally why you can never get ahead, something I learned with every single Intel computer I've purchased, especially when their anticompetitive practices forced AMD to bet on Bulldozer and get slaughtered on IPC, but no one mentioned us creatives rocking 9590's for 80% off leeching electricity off our landlords in illegal basements, building our entire businesses simply because AMD gave us chips that suddenly could render, animate, compress, KEEP UP, and despite the limitations, kept money in my pocket for me to spend on my LIFE, not online.
    I understand this is newer tech, but let's all take a moment to acknowledge that Intel would NEVER offer 28 cores (what a weird number must tie to die size) unless AMD forced their hand, 2990WX is AMD taking BACK the crown, AND WITH CHIPLET DESIGNS, I forsee that with just a BIOS update, I can literally update to the next king from here on out, resell this processor (I never overclock and when you see what I'm 3D printing to ensure perfect TR4 thermal paste applications) and use the difference as a "coupon" to stay constantly ahead of Intel from here on out.
    God DAMN I FEEL GOOD TO BE BACK ON TEAM RED. Lol @220MB/s steady into 3x Firecuda 2TB in a Storage Space as RAID 1. Intel has NOTHING that can offer clock + core and won't even when they hit 10nm (while GloFo / AMD will be well into 7nm by then)

    In the time it would take for them to invent the architecture to get rid of seeking perfect one-die pieces that perform high enough to be top tier silicon, AMD can develop on over 5 years of development from investors (who invest through buying Faildozer and HBM1) to now completely put BOOTS to Intel.
    With the TR4 die space, I forsee 64 Cores on 7NM with ~400w thermals @ 4.3-4.5ghz. If you're on Intel? Stop pretending those socket updates don't suck. TR4 was designed for expanding into the socket size and bandwidth, PCI-E lane accessibility, and more.
    Anyone who was born in 1991 and grew up with a computer from the days of beige towers and CRT monitors will attest that AMD is the only solution for anyone who doesn't throw money away like they would their life.

    • Nova Exclusives
      Nova Exclusives Месяц назад

      Forgot to mention: 220MB/s at highest compression level from .ARW / .JPEG files that normally would trash computers with the varying file sizes and types. The core count basically hides any single process that won't "compress" at full speed and with AMD Ryzen Master Utility, it will turbo any single cores to maxiumum speed based on set TDP.
      Even more appealing is that the AMD software identifies the strongest cores within your processor, the second strongest, and basically tabulates the per-die, PER CORE PERFORMANCE and gives you the best it can give.
      I may not be at 4ghz but coming from 6 cores, 12 hyperthreaded to 32? Seeing every benchmark leaving SPADES of room in the CPU? I'm confident that AMD FineWine is back.

  • Clovet Music
    Clovet Music Месяц назад

    Intel
    "We need money so let's give them 4 less cores at over 9 thousand dollars more! Have fun hyper threading!"

  • Zeek M
    Zeek M Месяц назад

    Lambo gets kick backs from intel.

  • Ilia Korvigo
    Ilia Korvigo Месяц назад

    I'd like to point out that Intel CPUs are still way more optimised for computational tasks. Even "cheap" 6-8 core Intel CPUs outperform Ryzen and Threadreaper chips at operations involving MKL, BLAS and LAPACK, that is almost all maths-heavy stuff.

  • Seductive Wizard
    Seductive Wizard Месяц назад

    When 2 giants go nuts!

  • Panther001
    Panther001 Месяц назад

    I am freinds with an intel engineer, intel has nothing new. As of a fact the new kaby lake is the exact same as the previous one just with more power. The management is bad so they dont know what to do. They literally force the engineers to give them ideas every month or so. They have no clue what to do

  • jack chester
    jack chester Месяц назад

    your forgetting one thing threadripper is consumer grade (high end but still) and xeon is server grade. put threadripper next to I9 x series for a fair comparison or epyc vs xeon.

  • Kevin Garren
    Kevin Garren Месяц назад

    So Intel's fanboys show us the latest stupid expensive intel shit. 99.99% of people will never even see muchless use. The whole point of your channel is stupid. Let me show you a bunch of shit you'll never be able to afford or use. Isn't this interesting No It's Not!! Thumbs down and finally unsubed from the "look what you can do with a 30K PC".

  • EyeInTheSky
    EyeInTheSky Месяц назад

    This is the worst and most pointless head to head I have ever had the misfortune to view. "lets take a much older generation processor that was build for enterprise data and stick it on a bodge job motherboard firmware motherboard and compare it to a CPU on a verified and tested firmware and motherboard combo that was built and tested specifically for these synthetic tests

  • Silvesther Lusion
    Silvesther Lusion Месяц назад

    It's funny how everything has to be a 'killer', as in the next best thing has to 'kill', commit to murdering it's predecessor or competition. Seriously, does something always need to die?

    • Boomer8824
      Boomer8824 Месяц назад

      Silvesther Lusion it’s all metaphoric though. It means to dominate or rule over another piece of hardware

  • Games Master
    Games Master Месяц назад

    Threadripper 2 is best in editing and Xeon is best in gaming

  • Richard Herring
    Richard Herring Месяц назад

    Intel on threadripper 2.0: it’s only cheaper and faster. But they glue it together so spend 8 more grand on an intel cpu.

  • Abhishek Garg
    Abhishek Garg 2 месяца назад

    Linus please make a video to build a machine for machine learning and Artifical intelligence.

  • JR
    JR 2 месяца назад

    even the first one is a good buy man. And the Haswell revision is still fine too man.

  • DabTheGanja Twitch
    DabTheGanja Twitch 2 месяца назад

    Its nice to see them getting their asses kicked beyond what should be possible

  • Nanoryu
    Nanoryu 2 месяца назад

    man did you see the price?

  • Dr. Etzor
    Dr. Etzor 2 месяца назад

    Can you really call it a Threadripper Killer if it's 5 times more expensive than 32 core Threadripper tbh.

  • Georg C
    Georg C 2 месяца назад

    dejavu that kind of rendering speed i saw in times of intel 286 struggled to show a single picture.

  • IraQ Nid
    IraQ Nid 2 месяца назад

    Phree Willy!

  • aaditya mc kinnon
    aaditya mc kinnon 2 месяца назад

    Amd fanboy hit like If u same💖

  • Cameron Zukoff
    Cameron Zukoff 3 месяца назад

    Wasn't planning on finishing the video until I saw the Total Annihilation box, still have the CD's and play them often.

  • DJ ArcForce
    DJ ArcForce 3 месяца назад

    Yay AMD wins at doing something like 1% of CPU buyers need it to do.... lol. The rest of us, who are gamers, will stick to paying a little bit more for #1, by a significant margin, single core performance. Call me when AMD gets their single core performance up above Intel's for more than a couple months. 9th gen Coffee Lake just released and while it is just a refresh, they've made some nice changes. And the new flagship i9 is only $488 (MSRP) That's $488 for top level Intel, 8 core, 16 thread, #1 gaming performance ladies and gents. AMD can't answer that.

  • Cipi SixZeroFour
    Cipi SixZeroFour 3 месяца назад

    Intel is for losers

  • HashTagRealName
    HashTagRealName 3 месяца назад

    Anybody else notice the words written on the side of the apple (fruit) on the desk? Who understands the reference???

  • Nick Miller
    Nick Miller 3 месяца назад

    More like _too magny cours_ amirite?

  • Okoko Anainga
    Okoko Anainga 3 месяца назад

    Go AMD

  • Alex Crossland
    Alex Crossland 3 месяца назад

    why bother trying to compete with ThreadRipper? AMD has cornered the high thread count workspace. sorry intel but it's true. maybe you should concentrate on trying to reclaim the gamers market from Ryzen? just a thought

  • Talha Khalid
    Talha Khalid 3 месяца назад

    Blender animation sucks on my machine it took 3 days to render 30 sec animation

  • Talha Khalid
    Talha Khalid 3 месяца назад

    Linus I am a big Doom fan layed almost every version of it now i develop maps for it

  • Liquid
    Liquid 3 месяца назад

    but can it run minesweeper?

  • Niarbeht
    Niarbeht 3 месяца назад

    Someone call Canadian OSHA, looks like Linus runs an unsafe workplace with those dangling BRIGHTER-THAN-THE-SUN lights.

  • DANK
    DANK 3 месяца назад

    you forgot to do fps_max 1000 on csgo

  • Never Yield
    Never Yield 3 месяца назад

    Intel can crank it up to a similar power consumption and rule once again.

  • MrDmd74
    MrDmd74 3 месяца назад

    Intel who?

  • RoffaboyS
    RoffaboyS 3 месяца назад

    The company I work at doesn't even got any Intel processors in stock besides the 8086K. WTH is Intel doing AMD is beating them like crazy in price and performance.

  • RoboticusMusic
    RoboticusMusic 3 месяца назад +1

    How much more powerful can single core CPU processing get on silicon theoretically? 2x? 3x? If I buy the flagship Intel CPU in about 1 year will it basically never be obsolete until graphene CPU's come out?

  • Cloud Reider
    Cloud Reider 3 месяца назад

    Linus, I'd be interested to see if these same rigs game any differently using Vega cards instead of GTX cards (since AMD owns Radeon?)

  • Q5Grafx
    Q5Grafx 3 месяца назад

    i bet that intel chip is only $6000

  • Nohara Loco
    Nohara Loco 3 месяца назад

    Lol yup Im stoked with threadripper 2.
    Not impressed by intels rehashed over priced competition.
    This gives me hope that the next gen ryzen with zen architecture 2 will be pretty nice.

  • OmniscientWarrior
    OmniscientWarrior 3 месяца назад

    For all the AMD fanboys out there, like myself. You don't really need to worry about the Threadripper killer. AMD already has a Threadripper killer killer made, EPYC. It costs about 8 grand.

  • MaX Falstein
    MaX Falstein 3 месяца назад +1

    The AMD Threadripper 2 was always going to come out on top but I was not expecting the Blender result to be that much quicker on Threadripper 2.
    Poor Linus, he can talk about "pinch of salt" as much as he likes but he must be having a crisis about Intel.
    I would like to see two 8180 CPUs vs. one and two AMD Epyc SoC(s).

  • Impalement Stream
    Impalement Stream 3 месяца назад

    Anyone else notice the matching poop brown backplate on that GPU at 4:50?

  • Princess Peach
    Princess Peach 3 месяца назад

    You pronounce zed funny.....

  • Mopantsu
    Mopantsu 3 месяца назад

    One of those game benchmarking apps (OCAT) you probably use missreports FPS on screen but is correct in the logs. Many tech journos get caught out by this. It was mentioned by AdoredTV in one of his recent videos. ru-clip.com/video/4gmo9AXbNlA/видео.html?t=541

  • Chia chin Lo
    Chia chin Lo 3 месяца назад

    AMD Work used SO good ,But Intel Play Game so good . I like AMD ........

  • i love street
    i love street 3 месяца назад

    #JIMKELLER

  • i love street
    i love street 3 месяца назад

    ....JIM KELLER, BITCH!!! And now he is working at INTEL with a black ops budget....???? WHAT!!!

  • i love street
    i love street 3 месяца назад

    ...Oh BOI!!! @9:47 you remind me how I want one of them orange things.

  • i love street
    i love street 3 месяца назад

    ....wtf,, who is still using gtx these dayz? RTX MAN!!!!

  • Andre Woods
    Andre Woods 3 месяца назад

    Should have underclocked and turned off 4 cores on the threadripper

  • Andre Woods
    Andre Woods 3 месяца назад

    Only one gig of ram per core smh

  • Oriell003
    Oriell003 3 месяца назад

    all the results gave me hypertension

  • Bill Kariri
    Bill Kariri 3 месяца назад

    Task manager porn

  • Cristian Radu
    Cristian Radu 3 месяца назад

    So Intel Tech Tips made a movie again?

  • JayzBeerz
    JayzBeerz 3 месяца назад

    intel will always own amd

  • euga
    euga 3 месяца назад

    Head to head in windows? Has microsoft updated so that threadripper isn't limited in windows 10 (in comparison to linux)?

  • Blu Stallion
    Blu Stallion 3 месяца назад

    Bah, intel is losing the nanometer race anyway. I think they’ll be overtaken by amd’s zen series sometime relatively soon.

  • usb_hub
    usb_hub 3 месяца назад

    my 4790K still runs fine

  • Techlappy
    Techlappy 3 месяца назад

    Yo linus

  • E L
    E L 3 месяца назад

    $10,000 vs $1700 ? I would buy 5 AMD and 5 times more performance than Intel.

  • KontraNinja
    KontraNinja 3 месяца назад +1

    I saw a Video of Der8auer he overclocked two AMD Epyc 7601 on 4 Ghz which was faster than 4 intel 28-core xeon platinum 8180. AMD CPU 4500€ and Intel CPU 10.000€ also 9000€ vs 40.000€ this is askicking for intel

  • Rommie Samboski
    Rommie Samboski 3 месяца назад

    Fuck man Linus has such a chiselled and handsome face no homo.

  • Dr. Fresh_2k
    Dr. Fresh_2k 3 месяца назад +1

    WOW! Look at the bezels on that threadripper monitor.

  • kofteburger
    kofteburger 3 месяца назад

    It's treason then.

  • flameshana9
    flameshana9 3 месяца назад

    Isn't this just the same as my computer from 2008? Six cores beats Intel's 2/4 cores? Brute force has been AMD's method since then.
    So isn't this just an entire decade of 1-upping each other in the very same way? I don't understand how you can get excited about it.

  • Вася Пупкин
    Вася Пупкин 3 месяца назад

    Like for wolfenstein 3d, doom, doom 2, unreal and total annihilation! Nostalgia=)

  • Ich heisse Nomad
    Ich heisse Nomad 3 месяца назад

    The Heliumman is back.

  • Warwick Palm
    Warwick Palm 3 месяца назад

    Love videos with no teleprompter, so much more enjoyable when Linus is just talking to us.

  • ToxicBatosss
    ToxicBatosss 3 месяца назад

    People saying Xeon should be compared to Epyc, seriously fuck you.
    The 2990WX costs 1/5 of Intel's price and destroys it in every benchmark apart from gaming, but who the fuck would play games on a machine like this?????

  • shea kyll
    shea kyll 3 месяца назад

    massive tdp? amd was making cpu's with 220 watt tdp's 5 years ago, 205 is not that high.......

  • ladjkaoz
    ladjkaoz 3 месяца назад

    where can i get that power meter

  • ladjkaoz
    ladjkaoz 3 месяца назад +1

    where can i get that power meter

    • flameshana9
      flameshana9 3 месяца назад

      I can't be sure, but it looks very similar to the one I bought from a Home Depot. Mine is from a company called Blue Planet.

  • Akhilesh Bhatt
    Akhilesh Bhatt 3 месяца назад

    how come their are Hindi subtitle in the video

  • Akhilesh Bhatt
    Akhilesh Bhatt 3 месяца назад

    never thought but people with more money than brains is a last segment of customers

  • Brian
    Brian 3 месяца назад +1

    Man, this guy really has to be less of a cartoon.

    • Webbie
      Webbie 3 месяца назад

      technically he is a cartoon. The real Linus died over 5 years ago from an overclocking incident. This Linus is a CGI render of the real one, voiced by troy baker if i remember correctly.

  • RedLeben
    RedLeben 3 месяца назад

    something completely off the actual topic, is the benq monitor better than the LG one. It appears to be so on the video.

  • LewisR09
    LewisR09 3 месяца назад

    how much for that big box copy of total annihilation?

  • Squall4Rinoa
    Squall4Rinoa 3 месяца назад

    Linus, if you happen to have a x399 Zenith Extreme on hand, can you test with Turing + Turing or Turing + Volta or Volta+Volta combinations to see if it will boot?
    Several users now have found it hits 0E error when trying to SLI 2080's or doing a deep learning config with a Titan V + 2080.

  • Tomas T
    Tomas T 3 месяца назад

    ...now his shadow is burned into the wall....

  • David Acevedo
    David Acevedo 3 месяца назад

    i'm so glad i found this channel.. please keep doing what u guys r doing, dont sell out and dont change a thing :)

  • kram Null
    kram Null 3 месяца назад

    Well AMD fans we can all pat our wallets on the back for buying their junk for 20 years.... They finally made a round of processors that aren't defective unlock-able time bombs...

  • Ice Buble
    Ice Buble 3 месяца назад

    But did you know AMD Bottleneck nVidia GPU's? and that's why if u use AMD + nVidia you will have lower performance in games even tho you have same numbers as Intel + nVidia.

  • Nabil collo
    Nabil collo 3 месяца назад

    Any idea when zen 2 ( 3rd gen may be 3700x ) relase date ?!

  • fsjack
    fsjack 3 месяца назад

    clickbait alert

  • Dennis
    Dennis 3 месяца назад

    Those coolers are cute, im running a noctua nh-d14 for my r3 1200 oc in a matx case xD

  • wolfen750
    wolfen750 3 месяца назад

    The Red Wave Is Real.

  • Shannen Thor
    Shannen Thor 3 месяца назад

    Whats the temp sensor reading 100c+?!

  • agr metor
    agr metor 3 месяца назад

    So the threadripper overclocks, and when the Intel actually comes out, it will too?

  • rings of fire
    rings of fire 3 месяца назад

    Thank you Linus. Great Vid. Let's not forget that Intel can't actually deliver actual units, being they are outsourcing for their 14NM consumer cpus. Beginning to look alot like Christmas.... For AMD. More Ryzen by necessity for retailers. Then Q1 and Q2 of 2019. Shit's feeling pretty real for them. Already won by Tom's Hardware with Product of the Year Award for Ryzen. Gaming CPU of the year with 2700x (I bought and built with opening day) Hey, know a winner when I see it... My Ryzen system worked immediately, no 4 hours of tomfoolery,btw. ANNNYYYWAYS. Great vid, great reflection on the dual phase cooled 28 core smoke and mirrors show with a mobo that consumers CAN'T buy. At least AMD showed up with actual products you can BUY TODAY AT MICROCENTER at the show. My BOYS! MY HEROES! Didn't want this to turn into a Microcenter commercial. But that's where I buy on release day. And weekly-half my paycheck goes there, lol, and that's ok! You want it, they got it. Period. And... If.... They were out of stock of anything... BITCH TO ME.. I'll escalate to the buyers. Power to the people. The builders. The people who need it NOW. If you are reading this and in the Denver Metro area, and want a 2990 WX system/build, stop in and ask for Glenn or Nate. Tell em Justin sent you. Mad server power in a desktop form factor, for ridiculous cheap price, scale wise. Golden.... Get the extras so they don't lose their ass while hooking YOU up. That's how they roll, so please realize;) You have two new friends at Microcenter, and if you're not in our area still drop my name. Might hook you up in the next two weeks.
    Really!!?? Yeah.. Try it. Yell as loud as you can, "AYYMD!!!!" as you walk into your local Microcenter. Scream it loud, especially if you own our stock. Walk into BYO section exclaiming again. OWN IT!!! No promises but bet you'll get extra special treatment. Ask for the two top sellers if the store, and tell em Justin from AMD sent me, and this is what YOU want. Best, award winning processor (Ryzen 2700X) and a mobo combo discount . There waiting. Threadripper 2 2990 WX if you're a baller like that, or truly can use it as a proper Prosumer. Photographers, Photo editors using Adobe Photoshop(Uses every core, thread and Gb of RAM you got!), video editors, audio editors, (Dr. Dre!!), hey you know who you are and you need more....On that note.... What up Dre!? Still here. Just been busy... Those in the BIZ KNOW... Reality is stranger than fiction.
    Still the same Justin, just working for EVERYONE (AMD partners) now... Ray tracing for over 10 years with Vray. Yes, on the right side, AMD partnership. Can't say nothin. Just wait and see..... The future is VERY bright... Ummm, the Ring of Fire is just getting rolling!!?... Um, yeah. No coincidence. Watch and learn my friends...... Watch and learn. HAHA,LOL

  • Chris Kamper
    Chris Kamper 3 месяца назад

    Nobody is designing CPUs for DAW use. :-(

  • ninetenduh
    ninetenduh 3 месяца назад

    The Total annihilation Retail Box in the background, I loved the game back in the days, KKND 2, Total Annihilation, and so on, with actual good and awesome Intros. Whos box is that? Is it Ivans?

  • Chase Rayfield
    Chase Rayfield 3 месяца назад

    EPYC 2 and Threadripper 3 will be out soon enough 3 and 8mos respectively most likely and are going to rip Intel to shreds. I say to shreds!!!

  • Trackside Model Railroading
    Trackside Model Railroading 3 месяца назад

    We have bought all Intel CPU's for as far as I can recall, our server room and all workstations have Xeon CPU's and all our desktops use the iSeries. This month after seeing what AMD can actually do at a far better price we will be buying our first AMD workstation in over 20 years. You just can't argue the performance vs dollar mark on the new chips, you'd be foolish to think different, either that or you are one that lies to yourself a bit too much. I have always loved Intel CPU's but this is a game changer for the workstation market. Intel shadowing PCI lanes and such just makes me feel like it is the right move. Sorry Intel you have had a good run but AMD has just proved them self to me and I can't believe they actually won me over. Crazy times.

  • zanityzoozoo
    zanityzoozoo 3 месяца назад

    AMD put themselves on the map by dropping big on the willie contest way back in the day at a fraction of the price. Intels always been about 'its how you use it that matters'

  • ryche rising
    ryche rising 3 месяца назад +1

    Just out of curiosity: Windows 10 is applying the Spectre and Meltdown "fix", EVEN without user consent, should you check if the intel CPU got patched and AMD "didn't apply"?