The Messed Up Origins Of Mulan

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 янв 2018
  • The real story behind Disney's Mulan.
    Subscribe to our channel: goo.gl/cv6b96
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Description:
    You have probably already watched the Disney movie “Mulan,” and you know that this hero would be your favorite Disney princess if she were part of royalty in China. But did you know that, even though we’ll never know if she existed or not, her fairy tale was actually based on a story that was told centuries ago? This is why we are showing you the messed up origins of Mulan.
    In the Disney movie, Mulan was supposed to become a housewife like many other women, but she failed the test with the matchmaker. This is why she decided that she was going to take her father’s place and her family was shocked when they found out about her decision. What happened in the original story?
    We all know that Mulan was not very skilled when she joined the army and she had to work hard to learn how to fight like a man in the movie. But in the original fairy tale, she already knew how to fight and practiced martial arts with her father.
    And we won’t forget about the love story with Li Shang. In one of the original tales, our favorite hero also fell in love with a man named Jin Yong. When he found out that she was a woman, he became more attached to her. Unfortunately, we don’t know how this fairy tale ended.
    Stay tuned if you want to hear more about the messed up origins of Mulan like what happened when she revealed that she was a woman and how her story really ended. So which tale do you prefer: the Disney movie or the original story? Don’t be shy to answer in the comments section down below. We love to hear what you think.

    -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Our Social Media:
    Facebook: facebook.com/TheThingscom/
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    For more videos and articles visit:
    www.thethings.com/
  • РазвлеченияРазвлечения

Комментарии • 4 747

  • Kindred
    Kindred 2 часа назад

    She didn't need no man, what does her father look to you; a woman?
    You also forgot the part where she was supposedly about to become a "concubine".
    At the descriptions, you wrote "The real story behind Disney's Mulan." which is wrong. Check your title and see if it fits your description.
    You should also slip another fact into that "war" fact, she had another woman accompanying her when she went to war.

  • Rheannon Wright
    Rheannon Wright День назад

    takingwork.com/?work=418

  • Justin
    Justin День назад

    Disney

  • Ello Bello
    Ello Bello День назад

    Well that thumbnails going to give me nightmares...

  • Tynne Vera Cruz
    Tynne Vera Cruz День назад

    i like it

  • Francesca Hart
    Francesca Hart День назад

    It’s a bit frustrating when people act like a woman should fall in love because “it’s better when she doesn’t need a man.” Most people fall in love and that doesn’t make them weak or less than.

  • 史宁婧
    史宁婧 2 дня назад

    I am chinese and this is NOT TRUE

  • AutisticDolphin&Friends
    AutisticDolphin&Friends 2 дня назад

    Stop bloody clickbaiting

  • Kids Kids
    Kids Kids 2 дня назад

    Disney

  • Sherene Salah
    Sherene Salah 2 дня назад

    How do you want to take the fantasy away? I don't like that..

  • yo beast
    yo beast 2 дня назад

    COPYING EXPOSED

  • Simran Kaur
    Simran Kaur 3 дня назад +1

    Original story

  • Alixis Austin
    Alixis Austin 3 дня назад

    Both to be honest

  • Kurt N
    Kurt N 3 дня назад

    Fuck Click-Baiters... Will NEVER Subscribe or Like.

  • kagsgirl
    kagsgirl 3 дня назад

    Oringal

  • jolovessquirrels
    jolovessquirrels 3 дня назад

    so I thought the emperor asked to marry her and you can't say no to him so instead she killed herself

  • Bianca
    Bianca 3 дня назад

    I like more the Disney movie !

  • Pinky13
    Pinky13 3 дня назад

    I definitely don’t prefer the version where she comes back and her father dies. That’s just horrible! It’s so sad and tragic.

  • Katlyn ofCairns
    Katlyn ofCairns 3 дня назад

    I don’t understand what was supposed to be “messed up” about this story.

  • Britt
    Britt 3 дня назад

    Maybe stop saying throughout you video to keep watching, it's a six minute video not an hour.

  • Kyle Reese
    Kyle Reese 4 дня назад

    Chinese history > American history

  • Kayla M Fassett
    Kayla M Fassett 4 дня назад

    The original story was better.

  • Grace MD
    Grace MD 4 дня назад

    Dont tap or click reed more

  • jhon doe
    jhon doe 4 дня назад

    Mulan was never a great warrior, notice how the people who record history are not the ones who actually participated in history. battles were not recorded by real soldiers who fought in the battle but by beta male scribes who sat far from the battle up a tree or on a hill side safe from the violence. these scribes were beta men too unfit for battle who would fantasize about a strong female warrior that was part of their perverted Neurosis

    and thats all Mulan ever was a masturbation fantasy created by a beta male scribe that just wanted to have sex with a women but was rejected by women for not being man enough

  • jhon doe
    jhon doe 4 дня назад

    the female warrior is complete myth, debunked bullshit, in ancient times from Rome to china men were expected to carry 80-100lbs of gear, even during the Vietnam war US soldiers with the latest "light weight technology" still carried over 70lbs of gear having to march a minimum of 20 miles under 90 degree heat. and we haven't gotten to the combat part, they had women put on 40 pounds of armor and weapons and in a mock battle she collapsed after 4 seconds!

    so this notion that a women could carry 70lbs of gear everyday up and down mountains for the next 6 months is completely laughable only a women would be stupid enough to believe the stories to be true

  • Wit_Beyond_Measure
    Wit_Beyond_Measure 4 дня назад

    Yea, this copied Jon Solo!

  • Carla Meister
    Carla Meister 4 дня назад

    She’s touted as a badass in the Disney movie, but the “real” story makes her seem way more badass

  • Lemon & Lime
    Lemon & Lime 4 дня назад

    Thieves this is Jon Solo’s video!!!!

  • Isaiah Washington
    Isaiah Washington 4 дня назад

    Disney should do a live remake of Mulan sticking to the original tale

  • Mr Sampson
    Mr Sampson 4 дня назад

    Reported for misleading thumbnail.

  • evilkittygurl
    evilkittygurl 4 дня назад

    And yet you missed the other story with her killing herself to prevent from becoming one of the emperor's concubines.

  • Ada Bezanidou
    Ada Bezanidou 4 дня назад

    Oh my general 😘😘😉

  • C Nystrom
    C Nystrom 4 дня назад

    Real origin story.

  • Name Last
    Name Last 5 дней назад

    5M views

  • Michael Song
    Michael Song 5 дней назад

    As usual, I like the original story better. Specifically, I like the version where she was in the army for 12 years, and when she returned, she found out that her father passed away. And then she mourned, since she was doing it for her father. I like the sad story ending, but not tragic story. And this was sad, and not tragic. Well, I guess it sort of is tragic, but I'm okay with it.
    Now, for the really horrifying origin stories... Try looking for Cinderella, Sleeping Beauty, and Red Riding Hood. And even Pocahontas.
    Especially Sleeping Beauty. Yikes.

  • Aima Ohi
    Aima Ohi 5 дней назад

    It’s not that messed up tbh

  • Lesly 101
    Lesly 101 5 дней назад

    Its not messed up at all wtf the only thing that is sad is that her dad originally dies

  • Kaotic Kat
    Kaotic Kat 5 дней назад

    I've heard another tale that was more sickening. It went something like she went into the war because her father couldn't but when they found out she was a woman they forced her into being the army's prostitute.... or something like that. I like the videos version better.

  • jravage77
    jravage77 5 дней назад

    This announcer really hates men doesn't she?

  • QuartuvLarry
    QuartuvLarry 5 дней назад

    Eff Disney

  • Shadow Galaxy
    Shadow Galaxy 5 дней назад

    Isn’t it rude saying all things FAKE things about Hua Mu Lan!?Why not stick to American history if you don’t EVEN KNOW Chinese history!Like your pissing me off!

  • Justin Puyear
    Justin Puyear 5 дней назад

    Can we flag the video for copying another RU-clipr?

  • Lucky Stop motion
    Lucky Stop motion 6 дней назад

    Roses are red I'm am to cool I just got clickbaited and so did u

  • the.pug. 1
    the.pug. 1 6 дней назад

    You stole this content.

  • Ayariyuki Kurosaki
    Ayariyuki Kurosaki 6 дней назад

    Didn’t really sound messed up.

  • MR M
    MR M 6 дней назад

    This video brought to you by Feminazi Rotten Crotch an Co. Clipping the nuts of males since the 1960's.

  • Pastellio Gothio
    Pastellio Gothio 6 дней назад

    6 mins of clickbaity crap

  • Bearded Wonder
    Bearded Wonder 6 дней назад

    Lol all I heard was I don't need no man and all women should feel the same

  • SuperScyth
    SuperScyth 6 дней назад

    Can you please explain mulan's story without pushing your sjw agenda with such dumb comments ridiculing the ancient chinese story about WAR AND DEATH. Seriously gender was definitely not the biggest issue those soldiers trying to protect their homes had. Leave the writing to the writers and 'not what you believe' should happen.

  • Comix Queen
    Comix Queen 7 дней назад

    omg this was on my recommended and i’m so glad i didn’t watch this, earlier this morning because it spoils the second movie, and i was bored so i decided to watch the second one for the first time so i’m glad i decided to watch the movie then find this xD

  • Rosa Lovo
    Rosa Lovo 7 дней назад

    Also we know that Mulan was a real woman. This isn't a fairy tale in China it's history

  • Makayla Noel
    Makayla Noel 7 дней назад

    your ruining the childhood of Disney! So please dont this again

  • Christina Ely
    Christina Ely 7 дней назад

    I like the Disney Version better

  • Enigma X
    Enigma X 7 дней назад

    What the hell does that image of anything to do with this video?

  • Kit cat smith
    Kit cat smith 7 дней назад

    So it’s wrong to love

  • Candi_Mochi 23
    Candi_Mochi 23 7 дней назад

    Jinyoung is also a member of "got7"

  • Spencer Cheung
    Spencer Cheung 7 дней назад

    Mulan is just a fiction character in the history. Her story was told by poem. She was not washing clothes but doing weaving before she joined the army.

  • Tyler Curry
    Tyler Curry 7 дней назад

    Forsure click baited. What was so messed up about it? Now I won't watch the other videos

  • Grey Fox
    Grey Fox 7 дней назад

    reporting for misleading

  • Stephanie A. Ishiguzo
    Stephanie A. Ishiguzo 7 дней назад

    U guys always seen to find a new ways to get more like can't u just accept the film the way they made it

  • Sélu Sunlight Anu-World
    Sélu Sunlight Anu-World 8 дней назад

    The original origins

  • Lineth
    Lineth 8 дней назад +1

    I like the Disney version better and I hope they do a mulan 3.

  • percykins
    percykins 8 дней назад

    I just spent half of this video listening to the disney version...which i already know

  • Lafizha Faraige
    Lafizha Faraige 9 дней назад

    That allmost scared me bet cool

  • Brenyn Aldridge
    Brenyn Aldridge 9 дней назад

    When I saw the 2nt one I no joke cried but I love Disney so I like the Disney better

  • Emma Mac Tse
    Emma Mac Tse 9 дней назад

    This video is so inaccurate! Btw I'm Chinese and have studied the Milan script, please don't believe this crap!

  • Mhajan Patton
    Mhajan Patton 9 дней назад

    Bullshit....
    Clickbaited....

  • Samantha Rose
    Samantha Rose 10 дней назад

    Some things were left out... :(

  • Betty Taliauli
    Betty Taliauli 10 дней назад

    Original all the way.

  • Dame Deviljho
    Dame Deviljho 10 дней назад

    F E M I N I S T S



    Are annoying

  • Guadalupe Florian
    Guadalupe Florian 10 дней назад

    Males who get inspired rather than threatened by a woman who has proved is better in a certain discipline or ability? Those are honorable man! Cheers for those who follow this values ❤️

  • Wikz Aotearoa
    Wikz Aotearoa 10 дней назад

    This is bullshit. Let the indigenous people tell Fa Mulan’s story! Clickbaited for real 😩

  • Pink Acid
    Pink Acid 10 дней назад +1

    I prefer the tale not told by you.

  • Artim_Evad
    Artim_Evad 10 дней назад

    PLAGARISM!!!!! DONT U UNDERSTAND THAT U STOLE THIS VIDEO?? DELETE IT BECAUSE THEN U HAVE NO SHAME!

  • Ev F.
    Ev F. 10 дней назад

    Disney what can I say who doesn't love a happy ending

  • lydia philip
    lydia philip 10 дней назад

    Wasn't this just a legend? ( Just asking)

  • Xx_Trinx_xX
    Xx_Trinx_xX 11 дней назад

    ᖇOᔕEᔕ ᗩᖇE ᖇEᗪ
    ᐯIOᒪETᔕ ᗩᖇE ᗷᒪᑌE
    I ᒍᑌᔕT GOT ᑕᒪIᑕK ᗷᗩIT Eᗪ
    ᗩᑎᗪ ᔕO ᗪIᗪ YOᑌ
    ʇɥǝ ɔɹǝɐʇoɹs ɐɹǝ ǝʌıl
    ⓉⓇⓎ ⓉⓄ ⒻⒾⒼⓊⓇⒺ ⓄⓊⓉ ⓌⒽⒶⓉ ⓉⒽⒶⓉ ⓁⒶⓈⓉ ⓁⒾⓃⒺ ⓈⒶⓎⓈ

  • Alyson Mackay
    Alyson Mackay 11 дней назад

    No part of this is 'messed up', sad reacts only

  • Crunchy Toes
    Crunchy Toes 11 дней назад

    How is any of this “messed up origins”

  • Tye Hughes
    Tye Hughes 11 дней назад

    This isn't messed up

  • 還能怎樣人生
    還能怎樣人生 11 дней назад

    Do you know what is really fake?
    This video.

  • Jo Mo
    Jo Mo 12 дней назад

    The father dying at the end seems more realistic......

  • Someone
    Someone 12 дней назад

    where do u get the source?
    Mulan's story is coming from this ballad:
    pages.ucsd.edu/~dkjordan/chin/chtxts/Muhlan.html

  • Immortal Kdude
    Immortal Kdude 12 дней назад

    Mulan is my favorite Disney movie ...

  • Naomi And her oc’s
    Naomi And her oc’s 12 дней назад

    DISNEY!!!

  • I Like Red
    I Like Red 12 дней назад

    Your channel is turd emoji

  • juneil binco
    juneil binco 12 дней назад

    GUYS UNSUBSCRIBE THIS SHIT! ITS DEFINITELY DISTURBING HOW CHANNELS LIKE THIS WOULD COPY CONTENT FROM OTHER CHANNELS AS WELL! THIS EXACT CONTENT AND FORMATION OF WORDS WAS ORIGINALLY FROM JON SOLO! HE ALREADY KNOWS ABOUT THIS. I HOPE HE FILE A COPYRIGHT COMPLAINT. IF YOU DONT BELIEVE ME I WILL PASTE THE LINKS BELOW. LINKS MEANING THERE IS ANOTHER WORD BY WORD VIDEO THEY COPIED FROM JON SOLO WHICH IS "MESSED UP ORIGINS OF POCAHONTAS"WHICH IS DISTURBINGLY WORD BY WORD COPIED FROM JON SOLO. NOT ONLY THAT, MANY OF THEIR VIDEOS WERE COPIED FROM OTHER CHANNELS AS WELL! I HOPE THIS CHANNEL WILL GET WHAT THEY DESERVE! HELP US REPORT THIS ON RU-clip!
    Links:
    ru-clip.com/video/pBvZL4gp8U8/видео.html&feature=youtu.be
    ru-clip.com/video/ICffpX5P9e8/видео.html

  • Jaely Alexandra Torres Rivera
    Jaely Alexandra Torres Rivera 13 дней назад +1

    I like Disney much better cuz the other one is so confusing

  • Martin Ivanov
    Martin Ivanov 13 дней назад

    She was actually beheaded in real life idk where you got your info..

  • Michealla Newbold
    Michealla Newbold 13 дней назад

    But actually history records showed that yes she was in charge of the emperors army but she was also o e of his favorite out of many wives. She wasn't in a love the general before her

  • Cherry Blossom
    Cherry Blossom 14 дней назад

    She's my fave Disney princess ❤❤

  • Rroos Gzz
    Rroos Gzz 14 дней назад

    3:51 movie?????

  • Jordan
    Jordan 14 дней назад

    What’s wrong with Mulan and whats his face loving each other? It doesn’t make her any less independent and strong. She frickin saved China, it wasn’t like she was a damsel in distress or anything like that. I don’t see the problem.

  • Rambo Rose
    Rambo Rose 14 дней назад

    Mulan is not a princess as she married a soldier

  • Sapphire Kay
    Sapphire Kay 15 дней назад

    唧唧复唧唧,木兰当户织。
    不闻机杼声,唯闻女叹息。
    问女何所思?问女何所忆?
    女亦无所思,女亦无所忆。
    昨夜见军帖,可汗大点兵,
    军书十二卷,卷卷有爷名。
    阿爷无大儿,木兰无长兄,
    愿为市鞍马,从此替爷征。
    东市买骏马,西市买鞍鞯,
    南市买辔头,北市买长鞭。
    朝辞爷娘去,暮宿黄河边。
    不闻爷娘唤女声,但闻黄河流水鸣溅溅。
    旦辞黄河去,暮至黑山头。
    不闻爷娘唤女声,但闻燕山胡骑声啾啾。
    万里赴戎机,关山度若飞。
    朔气传金柝,寒光照铁衣。
    将军百战死,壮士十年归。
    归来见天子,天子坐明堂。
    策勋十二转,赏赐百千强。
    可汗问所欲,“木兰不用尚书郎,
    愿借明驼千里足,送儿还故乡。”
    爷娘闻女来,出郭相扶将。
    阿姊闻妹来,当户理红妆。
    小弟闻姊来,磨刀霍霍向猪羊。
    开我东阁门,坐我西阁床。
    脱我战时袍,著我旧时裳。
    当窗理云鬓,对镜贴花黄。
    出门看火伴,火伴皆惊惶。
    同行十二年,不知木兰是女郎。
    “雄兔脚扑朔,雌兔眼迷离;
    两兔傍地走,安能辨我是雄雌!” whew this is the whole story of Mulan if you can understand it

  • Remy N.
    Remy N. 15 дней назад

    I heard that the army didn't find out who she was until the emperor wanted to honor her by taking her father's daughter as a concubine and upon learning her inevitable fate chose to kill herself.

  • Z Stefan
    Z Stefan 15 дней назад

    Hwa(Fa was a mistranslation due to Cantonese translators) Mulan was originally a song, a ballad, It wasn't “a post with her father's name on it”, it was a series of recruitment orders, the Khan(yes, that was the original ruler in the lyric because northern China was back then in control of a nomad people converted into Chinese) ordered every family to send fighting men into the army.
    "Buy a horse, a saddle" is a metaphor, Chinese literature tends to use such manner to demonstrate specific details, Mulan was born in Wei, especially Northern Wei Dynasty where soldiers were expected to fund themselves instead of equiped by the nation, however, it also indicated that the Hwa family was a military family, of which the regulars of the empire born from.
    Actually, female generals are not that strange of an idea to Chinese, in times of Northern Wei and later Tang empire, women were given limited freedom and skilled in warfare partially due to the converted-nomad origin of these dynasties, it also owes to all those fierce civil wars/invasions/genocides occurred in China at that period of time.

  • judea pihema
    judea pihema 16 дней назад

    the disney wun

  • ALEXANDRIA SERGENT
    ALEXANDRIA SERGENT 16 дней назад

    Would you believe me if I said that I have never watched Mulan?

  • wiinterx4
    wiinterx4 16 дней назад

    I prefer this story over the original. She was a strong woman in the movie but an even stronger woman in the original tale