The Messed Up Origins Of Mulan

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 янв 2018
  • The real story behind Disney's Mulan.
    Subscribe to our channel: goo.gl/cv6b96
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Description:
    You have probably already watched the Disney movie “Mulan,” and you know that this hero would be your favorite Disney princess if she were part of royalty in China. But did you know that, even though we’ll never know if she existed or not, her fairy tale was actually based on a story that was told centuries ago? This is why we are showing you the messed up origins of Mulan.
    In the Disney movie, Mulan was supposed to become a housewife like many other women, but she failed the test with the matchmaker. This is why she decided that she was going to take her father’s place and her family was shocked when they found out about her decision. What happened in the original story?
    We all know that Mulan was not very skilled when she joined the army and she had to work hard to learn how to fight like a man in the movie. But in the original fairy tale, she already knew how to fight and practiced martial arts with her father.
    And we won’t forget about the love story with Li Shang. In one of the original tales, our favorite hero also fell in love with a man named Jin Yong. When he found out that she was a woman, he became more attached to her. Unfortunately, we don’t know how this fairy tale ended.
    Stay tuned if you want to hear more about the messed up origins of Mulan like what happened when she revealed that she was a woman and how her story really ended. So which tale do you prefer: the Disney movie or the original story? Don’t be shy to answer in the comments section down below. We love to hear what you think.

    -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Our Social Media:
    Facebook: facebook.com/TheThingscom/
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    For more videos and articles visit:
    www.thethings.com/
  • РазвлеченияРазвлечения

Комментарии • 5 146

  • Neil Barco
    Neil Barco 7 часов назад

    dito pala hinango ang praybet benjamin

  • justin lin
    justin lin 20 часов назад

    Oh so its china I'm from China

  • Ğamer_Jëlly-ÆFriends GameÆ-Furrycat

    To defeat the huns

  • Ğamer_Jëlly-ÆFriends GameÆ-Furrycat

    I love mulan

  • Den Mapanda
    Den Mapanda День назад

    Loved the original story but wouldn’t mind a happy ending ❤️😜only thing that Disney had to change was the ending. The original story is more empowering for women. Ps no women needs a man to fight her bottle hence Mulan want to war. But it doesn’t mean she can’t fall in love and be loved it’s not a crime, and in the movie am pretty sure she saved the man and the country......... am so sick of hearing that women don’t need a man to save them. Like that the only reason women fall in love with the man is when they get saved by one. Most of the times the women do the saving like for example Mulan saved Shane and fall in love with him because he accepted that women and man can each protect each other and didn’t try to stop her from saving the country but helped and celebrate the fact that she was brave and strong enough to fight for her country. I also really liked the original where the family supported her decision to join the army.🤨😅😅

  • karen rosero
    karen rosero День назад

    It'd be great a mix of the best of evey tale...

  • The Flying Dutchman
    The Flying Dutchman 2 дня назад

    So you guys don’t know the tale off that when she came back here mother remarried after here father died and the man want it Mulan to be his concubine and to avoid that fate she kill here self

  • Scott Andrew Hutchins
    Scott Andrew Hutchins 2 дня назад

    WTF is the pic on the right in the still?

  • Ricky Hawlen
    Ricky Hawlen 4 дня назад

    Honestly,i want mulan 3

  • Wanna One Stan
    Wanna One Stan 4 дня назад

    Clickbaited much?

  • Caleb Orwa
    Caleb Orwa 5 дней назад

    I think I love the movie . Do you?

  • MV STUDIOS
    MV STUDIOS 7 дней назад

    assholes.

  • ruba rabania
    ruba rabania 7 дней назад +1

    actualy there is no original chinese mulan it was inspired by jeane d arc

  • Skky Gavin
    Skky Gavin 7 дней назад

    Boyh

  • Onur A
    Onur A 7 дней назад +2

    We know if she is existed or not. She didn't. Before disney movie there wasnt even a debate like that.

  • Lil PANDA Super
    Lil PANDA Super 8 дней назад

    Ohh hell na

  • broadway baby
    broadway baby 9 дней назад

    And the story is sort of like Joan of Arc, becase they had to prove themselves by helping the army

  • broadway baby
    broadway baby 9 дней назад

    Mulan is basically Yentl

  • Mystikiouz
    Mystikiouz 9 дней назад

    owh....I am soo shy to answer....someone help me...

  • Anna Garza
    Anna Garza 10 дней назад

    I LOVED THE ORIGINAL!!!!!!! Well the dad dying part was sad😢

  • Jessica Crabtree
    Jessica Crabtree 11 дней назад

    It's there a version of her original story?

  • shumpy xoxo
    shumpy xoxo 11 дней назад

    The original is better 100%

  • SweetHibiscus
    SweetHibiscus 11 дней назад

    I prefer the original

  • Bee Zero
    Bee Zero 11 дней назад

    so who is that in the thumbnail? someone explain please??

  • Antasia Hargrove
    Antasia Hargrove 11 дней назад

    Disney version

  • Gamer Colour
    Gamer Colour 12 дней назад

    I prefer the disney

  • Gamer Colour
    Gamer Colour 12 дней назад

    SHE still MY favourite disney princess

  • FENRIR-ART
    FENRIR-ART 12 дней назад

    I rather deal with the old musical from China on film than that Quest For Camelot and Mononoke Hime clone.

  • Periodic Dog
    Periodic Dog 14 дней назад

    EVERYONE DISLIKE THIS IS A COMPLETE COPY!!!!WATCH THE REAL ONE BY JON SOLO ru-clip.com/video/ICffpX5P9e8/видео.html&t=4s

  • Tom BOY
    Tom BOY 14 дней назад

    I've always loved Mulans balled but when Disney came out with Mulan I was little so I didn't really know but either way I think both are pretty cool

  • Makeyla Plays
    Makeyla Plays 14 дней назад

    I like the real one

  • Ereri cosplay
    Ereri cosplay 15 дней назад

    I heard the story was Mulan father was to old n sick so her little brother was gonna go to war witch is why she had the pet dog little brother but her little brother was only 12 so she took his place instead so he could live his child hood n her father wouldn't die

  • otakukonichiwa dontstareatme
    otakukonichiwa dontstareatme 16 дней назад

    Ofc disney haha

  • Pixel
    Pixel 18 дней назад

    You do know this is a legend

  • lexus morrow
    lexus morrow 19 дней назад

    These videos and this channel is a total rip off. Please come up with your own stuff.

  • TRELLKOL
    TRELLKOL 19 дней назад

    you stole this from jon solo

  • Andro Orchid
    Andro Orchid 21 день назад

    You just ruined the movie

  • Samsung GalaxyS2
    Samsung GalaxyS2 21 день назад

    I think I like the original because they know how strong woman can be

    • tara lang
      tara lang 13 дней назад

      in the disney movie she was strong they did not make her look weak at all.

  • Shadow of the night
    Shadow of the night 21 день назад +1

    How do you know and was the thumbnail to let us watch this

  • • LilShorty •
    • LilShorty • 22 дня назад

    Wow. This is so incorrect and actually laughing at myself for giving you a view.

  • marissa parker
    marissa parker 22 дня назад

    Both

  • Bob Butt
    Bob Butt 22 дня назад

    She did not do the story

  • MIN SUGA GENIUS JJANG JJANG MAN BBOONG BBOONG

    *_"Jin Young"_* it sounds like Jin-Hyung 😂😂👌

  • TheEletricThunder TV
    TheEletricThunder TV 24 дня назад

    Why does this vid have so much dislikes I’m just asking

  • Kkojhujvyi Cukfyo
    Kkojhujvyi Cukfyo 24 дня назад

    Hi mother fuckers can you please change the damn thumbnail

  • hammy
    hammy 25 дней назад

    OKay but the thumbnail??

  • jimasia jones
    jimasia jones 25 дней назад

    You are a beautiful woman you don’t need a man to tell you that you’re strong you’re already strong you’re beautiful and you are powerful don’t let anyone tell you that you can’t do things that boys can you just listen to your heart keep on going a dream is a wish your heart makes 😇

  • manchezter
    manchezter 25 дней назад

    fake

  • Gacha Clarity
    Gacha Clarity 25 дней назад

    Wow..

  • Magnus Chase
    Magnus Chase 26 дней назад

    Disney

  • GamingWithSophie
    GamingWithSophie 26 дней назад

    I hate this channel, they don’t cite their sources and They make up theories THAT MAKE ZERO SENSE

  • Arya Veil
    Arya Veil 26 дней назад

    You prefer the version where she doesn't fall in love? Oh I'm sorry, I didn't realize that a woman falling in love with a man made her weak and dependable on the man she falls for.
    "She doesn't need a prince to be a princess"
    Did you even watch the damn movie? Her love for him literally had nothing to do with her accomplishments. Those were her and he never took it easy on her. She saved China through her own strengths and the help of her friends. Friends. He wasn't even a love interest in the first movie till the end. She wasn't a hero because of _him_ she was a hero because of her actions.
    I'm sorry but it really pisses me off when people say stupid crap like that. Falling in love or having a partner doesn't make you weak. A strong and independent person can still look for love and remain that strong individual they were before. In fact her falling in love makes her even stronger.
    "No on in her heart and no one in her mind"
    Really? It is basic humanity to fall in love. To look for someone you want to create life with. There is nothing wrong with her falling in love with a man. In fact I would give her credit. She was in the midst of battle but she recognized him, everything about him, and despite that they could easily die, she still wanted to be with him. It takes strength, trust, and compassion to truly fall in love. Something she was easily capable of.
    She didn't _need_ him. She _wanted_ him. She wanted to share a life, adventure, experiences with him. He made her happy and she made him happy.
    If I misunderstand then I'm sorry but this I a big problem I have seen with feminazis.

  • Rue Stahl
    Rue Stahl 26 дней назад

    Disney Version.

  • Leora Matthews
    Leora Matthews 26 дней назад

    i prefer the ballad it seems more natural

  • Jada Peters
    Jada Peters 28 дней назад

    I prefer fake mulan

  • Just A Normal K-Pop Fangirl
    Just A Normal K-Pop Fangirl 28 дней назад

    Narrator: If you love Mulan as much as we do-
    Me: YEAH RIGHT!!! AS IF U LOVE MULAN!!! IF U LOVE MULAN THEN STOP RUINING IT!!! B!TCH!!!!

  • Emi and Lettie World
    Emi and Lettie World 28 дней назад

    I love your video so much it wants me to watch the movie every day

  • Satisfying SLIME
    Satisfying SLIME 28 дней назад

    Definitely the Disney one

  • Aubree Jackson
    Aubree Jackson Месяц назад

    Both

  • Areeba Khan
    Areeba Khan Месяц назад

    What is it with that picture then ??

  • Ronaldo Fryman
    Ronaldo Fryman Месяц назад

    You ever heard of stealing? Plagiarism? Well, your about to. On your legal notices.

  • The Baloguns
    The Baloguns Месяц назад

    Both

  • Jesse Bélanger
    Jesse Bélanger Месяц назад

    Fucking pc feminist bs

  • シツ
    シツ Месяц назад

    Mulan is japanese.

  • Cali Wright
    Cali Wright Месяц назад

    Maybe it's my Imaginative nature as a Fiction/Non-Fiction/Romantic Comedy Story Writer. Or my personal feelings about History and Historical Fact... But, I prefer both. The Disney Movie version because of the Awesome imagination behind it. The Real story Because it Depicts Historical Facts about what REALLY Happened. Although Both are great! Note: I only write stories as a hobby and passtime now...

  • Yvette Rodriguez
    Yvette Rodriguez Месяц назад

    This is bearable😭

  • Pat Watkins
    Pat Watkins Месяц назад

    Since it is stated thst there is no way to know what is the true version, and even if she actually existed at all, I like the Disney story of Mulan.

  • On WUN
    On WUN Месяц назад +1

    We all should learn the whole Ballad of Mulan by hearts in junior high in China, BUT not before we saw the Disney movie as a kid hahaha

  • Arwa Tota
    Arwa Tota Месяц назад

    Your videos are always click baits WHAT THE FUCK THATS Y I DONT SUBSCRIBE

  • Subatomic Plays2026
    Subatomic Plays2026 Месяц назад

    (Notice: This is not a rude comment)When I saw the Picture under "Real" I clicked the video. When I finished it, I knew there was nothing about that picture in the video. So why did you put it?

  • Catherine Dixon
    Catherine Dixon Месяц назад

    I do Kung fu.

  • PaytonKennedy Schaffner
    PaytonKennedy Schaffner Месяц назад

    I like the disney version more...Cause i love her and Shang

  • Elena
    Elena Месяц назад

    I always thought Mulan was really based on Joan of Ark

  • Brandon The Fuze
    Brandon The Fuze Месяц назад +1

    Being a female in the army WAS illegal, making the Disney movie somehow more realistic.

  • Apex-y-Mation _
    Apex-y-Mation _ Месяц назад

    the ballad of mulan was better [ps if u read this check out Apex-Y-Mation_/ me]

  • This is me Chevonne
    This is me Chevonne Месяц назад

    All the little mini clips that they show of other people, WHY WAS THERE NOT ONE BLACK PERSON!!! Seriously

  • Takiyah Smith
    Takiyah Smith Месяц назад

    Disny

  • Asande Zamatima
    Asande Zamatima Месяц назад

    I prefer the original story

  • Shanilla Peres
    Shanilla Peres Месяц назад

    The Disney version is way better

  • Gabriel-Izabella Ray
    Gabriel-Izabella Ray Месяц назад

    Why was the thumbnail so creepy but the story isn’t 😡

  • Trashcake233322 #
    Trashcake233322 # Месяц назад

    Yeah but who is the creepy girl in the thumbnail

  • Chemmow
    Chemmow Месяц назад

    Alright, people are arguing about this a lot... Was Mulan really Chinese or not? Just give me a straightforward answer.

  • Quick Guy
    Quick Guy Месяц назад

    ATTENTION ATTENTION! THIS VIDEO WAS STOLEN FROM THEORIST JON SOLO
    HE MADE ONE WEEKS BEFORE THIS CAME OUT AND THIS HAS THE SAME PRINCIPLES IN.

  • Lakitha Little
    Lakitha Little Месяц назад

    Disney

  • Psy Konai
    Psy Konai Месяц назад

    What's so messed up about that?

  • Janice Kelly-Spencer
    Janice Kelly-Spencer Месяц назад

    Disney

  • Stellinator XxMsp
    Stellinator XxMsp Месяц назад

    Well actually Mulan did get caught and instead of being killed she became the emperors sex slave in one version (l love that version)

  • Elly
    Elly Месяц назад

    I heard in another version when everyone found out she was forced into becoming a prostitute for the emperor

  • Little Unicorn
    Little Unicorn Месяц назад

    Roses are red,violets are blue,I know this doesn't rhyme but you click baited us..Disney is way better...you are ruining people's childhoods

  • leJINdary Puns
    leJINdary Puns Месяц назад

    So practically what I learned from watching this video is that your thumbnail is fake, and looks really disturbing making us viewers feel like we got clickbaited.

  • Эмилия Романова
    Эмилия Романова Месяц назад

    when mulan saves her entire country from huns but elsa is revered as the most empowering and courageous disney princess
    edit: also this channel is shit. i'm sick of seeing it in my feed

  • Stephanie Fang
    Stephanie Fang Месяц назад +2

    Mulan is a real story......

    • Stephanie Fang
      Stephanie Fang 20 дней назад +1

      Shadow of the night I agree

    • Shadow of the night
      Shadow of the night 21 день назад +1

      Stephanie Fang that is true i mean how did she know the story in the vid. She is just making things up

  • Lucas Male
    Lucas Male Месяц назад

    This video was dogshit

  • Joleanna Mckelvey
    Joleanna Mckelvey Месяц назад

    original

  • Blue Ghost Town
    Blue Ghost Town Месяц назад

    3:01 TAEHYUNG!?!??!

  • Abbs 💋
    Abbs 💋 Месяц назад

    Okayy there was a lot with a woman going to war in ancient China because it was punishable by death!! That’s why she had to disguise herself as a man until she was so high ranked, it MIGHT be over looked by officials.
    In today’s society we know differently but I truly dislike the agenda the narrative took in this video. If you’re telling history, you need to tell FACTS! Leave your opinions out of it 😒😒

  • Neppy Yetti
    Neppy Yetti Месяц назад

    .... There wasn’t even a love story, and the soldiers only found out she was a girl AFTER the war ended when Mulan went back to her village... Her parents searched for her since she went out alone, but Mulan was said to be far away so she couldn’t hear their shouts. The emperor gave her a camel (as in the poem.) Mulan had brothers and sisters, just no elder brother. NOBODY KNEW HER GENDER ALL ALONG UNTIL THE WAR ENDED AND MULAN WENT BACK HOME...

    • Neppy Yetti
      Neppy Yetti Месяц назад

      I still dont understand why the titles is called “messed-up”..

  • Avichen Kei
    Avichen Kei Месяц назад

    There is also another early play script that the emperor offered his daughter to be married to mulan.

  • Thea Bartch
    Thea Bartch Месяц назад

    They are wrong on some of their facts.

  • Destanie Chandler
    Destanie Chandler Месяц назад

    both