Private Investigator Guesses Who's Lying: Horrific First Date Stories

  • Published on Sep 21, 2019
  • Real-life P.I. Elisabeth tries to guess which first date horror stories are true and which is a lie. Can you figure it out before she does?
    Check out more awesome videos at BuzzFeedVideo!
    BuzzFeed’s flagship channel. Sometimes funny, sometimes serious, always shareable. New videos posted daily!
    To see behind-the-scenes & more, follow us on Instagram @buzzfeedvideo
    Love BuzzFeed? Get the merch! BUY NOW:
    Licensed via Audio Network

    blue dust particle
    zirconicusso/Getty Images
    Blue Shine. Loop
    Chek-zp/Getty Images

Comments • 187

  • Benjamin Headrick
    Benjamin Headrick 16 hours ago

    It was obvious. She said she matched up with this "cutie" on Tinder, and then we she got to the date location she "didn't even know what she looked like"...

  • Skipp 914
    Skipp 914 2 days ago

    Elizabeth has a Trap House key around her neck.

  • iiCxtie
    iiCxtie 5 days ago

    Lol I actually guessed her because of the faces she was making she looked scared

  • John Do
    John Do 8 days ago

    Such a creep 🤢

  • Kate 1221
    Kate 1221 8 days ago

    she seemed high at the moment lol

  • Helen J
    Helen J 10 days ago

    Nadia reminds me of Queenie from Fantastic Beasts

  • Béatrice bouchard-p
    Béatrice bouchard-p 10 days ago

    Shes so insecure
    Maybe some imposter syndrome

  • Yeet Job
    Yeet Job 11 days ago

    i guessed when she said i accidentally ate a hash cookie thinking it was a regular

  • Cory Smith
    Cory Smith 16 days ago +1

    Omg..he said miget..

  • Sonia S
    Sonia S 16 days ago

    Im not gonna lie. Elisabeth's a hottie

  • jayson R
    jayson R 16 days ago

    the red-haired girl kind of looked like Miley Cyrus.

  • Tristan
    Tristan 16 days ago +1

    i feel like i just watch these videos now to hear the stories because i’m interested

  • Kate Fradgley
    Kate Fradgley 17 days ago +1

    Is it just me or does Elizabeth look like Rachael from friends??

  • Jailene-bee
    Jailene-bee 20 days ago

    Nadia for sure who tf has a bowl of edibles in their house? 😂

  • Jiah Frost
    Jiah Frost 22 days ago +1

    You don’t feel edibles that quickly, normal cookies aren’t that small and edibles don’t taste any different from normal food

    • Jess Steele
      Jess Steele 17 days ago

      You’ve never seen a small cookie? 😂😂

  • Anastasia Victoria
    Anastasia Victoria 22 days ago +2

    I sort of thought she was lying because she said "we weren't really hungry, but wanted to share a plate" and also later said "the waiter brought two full plates"

  • Bethany Gabrielle
    Bethany Gabrielle 23 days ago +5

    Bare curious about her face 😂 how much surgery has she had

  • Rebecca Fritz
    Rebecca Fritz 24 days ago +14

    am i the only one who thinks that the private investigator looks like jennifer aniston?

  • brizzleyoh
    brizzleyoh 25 days ago

    Did they really both use the term midget...?

  • TravelingYeti12
    TravelingYeti12 26 days ago

    Why do I always read these as "Pirate Investigators"... I am so decieved when the video starts!

  • Beata Blomberg
    Beata Blomberg 26 days ago

    how about this: 3 PIs do the 2 truths and a lie while a police detective or interrogator tries to figure out who's lying

  • Celeste
    Celeste 26 days ago +1

    Chloe from Lucifer looks different here

  • Puppy Lover
    Puppy Lover 26 days ago +1

    I guessed nadia😁

  • Pro God Pro life Pro Gun

    I knew it was Nadia. I don’t listen to the story I watch body language and way of speaking. She was blinking and moving a lot which is an indication of someone lying. Also she was stuttering a lot and didn’t seem confident in what she was saying.

  • loser laurie
    loser laurie 27 days ago

    the girl who got high is so cute

  • Juliet
    Juliet 27 days ago

    Why does she remind me of ijustine

  • Elisabeth Terceiro
    Elisabeth Terceiro 28 days ago +1

    haha i have the same first name (same spelling, 's' not 'z') as the pi

    • Elisabeth South
      Elisabeth South 21 day ago

      Elisabeth Terceiro mine is actually with an S. They just spelled it wrong LOL

  • Gaby Reyes
    Gaby Reyes 28 days ago

    Why is that last girl so soft spoken 😂

  • Gary Darth
    Gary Darth 28 days ago +1

    Great episode none the less but I was kind sad John wasn’t there

  • gg
    gg 29 days ago

    I was on a date and puked very contained in one of those large place napkins completely silently. It’s possible if you want it hard enough.

  • Ranson Tham
    Ranson Tham 29 days ago +2

    Observation from all the PI videos: if a person does not get too excited when telling a story, they are probably telling the truth because they have told it many times.

  • amal zuhair
    amal zuhair 29 days ago

    So John isn’t in this video? Why what happened?

  • K P
    K P 29 days ago

    I guessed her right! Lol

  • Laney K
    Laney K 29 days ago +2

    This is the only ridiculously obvious one that I've seen so far.

  • swight dhrute
    swight dhrute 29 days ago +5

    The other lies were so much less dramatic than the liars one, made it harder to believe.

  • grace webb
    grace webb 29 days ago +2

    the girl that was lying was so odd lol and obviously lying

  • 50 subs with no videos
    50 subs with no videos 29 days ago +3

    Noooo, where’s my boi hopper at

  • trey porter
    trey porter 29 days ago +1

    i went on a group date one time and the girl i was with laughed so hard at a joke i told that she threw up in her hands and i had to help her clean it up with napkins at the table but we were both laughing so hard.

  • lia
    lia 29 days ago +17

    shark: ok but where’s the john

  • Elizabeth
    Elizabeth 29 days ago

    No you was a set up chick 🙄 get outttttt of hereeee

  • NerdyHomosapian
    NerdyHomosapian Month ago

    I thought it was the girl on the left >.

  • elpida menounou
    elpida menounou Month ago +363

    My only question is...


  • 0601 96
    0601 96 Month ago

    Jasmines story was lame

  • Lola May
    Lola May Month ago

    nadia was so obvious

  • Akasha Snow
    Akasha Snow Month ago +3

    I just want to point out that at the beginning Nadia said that the edibles were cupcakes then she said that they were cookies.

    • Rylie Ayn
      Rylie Ayn 12 days ago

      Akasha Snow
      she didn’t??

  • foodismysoulmate
    foodismysoulmate Month ago

    Can you get a better liar please?

  • Brianna Lyons
    Brianna Lyons Month ago

    I knew she was lying because she kept talking about how she was going to meet up with some “cutie”, but then she went on to say that once she got to the restaurant she didn’t even know what this girl looked like. Contradictory, and doesn’t make any sense 😂 lol. Love these videos though! They’re entertaining

    • Exotic Cats
      Exotic Cats 22 days ago

      Brianna Lyons I find that you shouldn’t give too much information unless asked for more. Someone asks about how someone looks, don’t give their name, favorite food, and then what they look like. Also, not using an actual name isn’t good so thanks for pointing that outl

  • Dinesh Patel
    Dinesh Patel Month ago

    I enjoying watching this ...But this is getting too much you are stuck to one thing not providing other content

  • Kittikat4124
    Kittikat4124 Month ago +3

    I think John might have tracked down the shark

  • elyvion
    elyvion Month ago

    As soon as she said she wasn’t that hungry I knew she was lying

  • Kirstyn White
    Kirstyn White Month ago +186

    edibles don’t hit that quick, that’s how i knew she was lying 😂😂

  • Kristina Bryant
    Kristina Bryant Month ago

    Girl in the middle looked like Noah Cyrus and I was like wait what

  • Sara !
    Sara ! Month ago

    This was so obviouse

  • ChicagoTurtle1
    ChicagoTurtle1 Month ago +87

    But I think this is the wrong test for the wrong profession. She a PI - not a police detective, interrogator, psychiatrist, or my mom.

    • ChicagoTurtle1
      ChicagoTurtle1 10 days ago

      Seth Doan. PIs interrogate? In real life, they just collect data through different means and report to their customer. Imho.

    • Seth Doan
      Seth Doan 10 days ago

      Okay but she is an interrogator. PI’s interrogate

    • Elisabeth South
      Elisabeth South 21 day ago +1

      Very true! Lol

    • justalittlebitmo
      justalittlebitmo 29 days ago +43

      Your comment just made me think--This show with a panel of moms figuring out who's lying would be amazing 😂

  • Jordan R
    Jordan R Month ago +3

    Contained puking does happen. I once vomited entirely into the hole of a soda can. No mess.

  • leaves0fpurple
    leaves0fpurple Month ago

    Jasmine's job sounds so fun!

  • Mabi Bibi
    Mabi Bibi Month ago +3

    I knew it was Nadia because when Madison started telling her story Nadia was looking down and it was like she was memorizing what to say

  • Shrek T
    Shrek T Month ago

    i guessed the last one immediately, but thought it seemed too obvious so changed to the middle one

  • Gris
    Gris Month ago

    I'm gonna go on my first date ever this tuesday

    • Lara Martin
      Lara Martin 28 days ago +1

      Gris ohmyword seriously? Nah fam. He’s not worth wasting your time. 😱👏🏻👏🏻

    • Gris
      Gris 28 days ago

      @Lara Martin it was supposed to be tonight but he told me he can't come :((((

    • Lara Martin
      Lara Martin 28 days ago

      Gris HOW WAS IT?!?!?!?!?!?!

  • tricia t
    tricia t Month ago +16

    Elizabeth is so pretty istg she’s like straight out of a private investigator movie